Creamy Seafood Stuffed Shells Recipe

There’s something irresistible about the combination of tender seafood nestled inside pasta shells, all wrapped in a creamy, flavorful sauce. This dish is the kind of indulgence you want to serve for a special occasion or when you’re craving something a little fancy but still comforting. The creamy sauce, paired with shrimp, lobster, and crab, brings the flavor of the sea to your kitchen in the most delicious way. The best part? Even though it looks like something you’d order at a fancy seafood restaurant, it’s actually quite easy to make at home!

this RECIPE

A personal seafood moment: a memory from the coast

I’ve always had a soft spot for seafood dishes, and they tend to remind me of trips to the coast. One summer, we spent a weekend near the ocean, and I remember stumbling upon a small, family-owned restaurant. They had the most incredible seafood pasta – rich, creamy, and stuffed to the brim with fresh shrimp, lobster, and crab. I’ve never forgotten that meal. So, when I first attempted this recipe, I knew I wanted to recreate that same creamy, savory bite that brought me back to the beach. Every time I make these seafood stuffed shells, it feels like a little taste of that vacation, even though I’m miles away from the coast.

The origin story: seafood + pasta = perfection

Seafood pasta is a staple in coastal cuisines, particularly in Italy, where seafood-filled ravioli or stuffed pasta dishes have long been part of the menu. This recipe draws on that tradition but adds a few modern twists, like the Old Bay seasoning, which gives it a bit of a kick. Over time, seafood stuffed shells have evolved, with chefs and home cooks experimenting with different fillings and sauces to keep things interesting. This version is all about creamy indulgence, but with just the right amount of fresh seafood flavor to balance it out.

Let’s talk ingredients: the stars of the dish

Each ingredient plays an essential role in bringing this dish together. Here’s a closer look at what you’ll need:

• Shrimp: These little morsels provide a sweet, delicate bite. I like to chop them into small chunks so you get a bit of shrimp in every bite. If you can’t find shrimp, scallops or even a firm white fish like cod could work as substitutes.
• Lobster meat: Lobster is luxurious and makes these shells feel like a special occasion dish. But if lobster isn’t available, you could swap it out for more shrimp or even a bit of salmon.
• Lump crab meat: This adds a soft, sweet texture to the filling. Make sure you’re buying good-quality crab. It should be sweet, not fishy, and firm to the touch. I’ve used canned crab in a pinch, but fresh or frozen is always better.
• Cream cheese: This gives the filling its creamy texture, and it also helps hold everything together when baking. Make sure it’s softened to room temperature for easy mixing.
• Spinach: Fresh spinach adds color and a little extra nutrition. If you’re using frozen spinach, just be sure to drain it really well so the filling doesn’t get too watery.
• Old Bay seasoning: This iconic seafood seasoning brings a bit of warmth and spice, rounding out the richness of the seafood and cheese.

Kitchen gear: what you need to make it happen

To pull off these creamy seafood stuffed shells, you don’t need anything too fancy in terms of kitchen tools, which is always a bonus. Here’s what you’ll want to have on hand:

• A 9×13 baking dish: This size works perfectly for fitting all the stuffed shells in one snug layer.
• Large skillet: You’ll use this for both the seafood and the sauce, so it’s helpful to have a skillet that heats evenly. If you don’t have a large skillet, you could use a medium one and work in batches.
• Mixing bowl: A big bowl is key for combining all the seafood, spinach, and cheeses for the filling. I find that using a larger bowl than you think you need makes mixing a lot easier (and less messy!).
• Foil: To cover the dish while baking and trap in moisture, ensuring those shells come out perfectly tender.

Step-by-step: my foolproof method for creamy seafood stuffed shells

1. Prepare the pasta shells

First up, we need to cook those jumbo pasta shells. Follow the package instructions, but make sure to undercook them by a minute or two. The shells will bake again, so we don’t want them getting too soft. When they’re done, rinse them in cold water to stop the cooking and prevent them from sticking together.

2. Make the creamy sauce

In a skillet, melt 1 tablespoon of butter over medium heat, then whisk in the flour. This will create a roux to thicken the sauce. Once it’s bubbly, add in the heavy cream, almond milk, and seafood broth, stirring until smooth. Toss in the minced garlic, Parmesan, and Italian seasoning. Keep tasting the sauce as it simmers – you want to make sure it’s seasoned just right. Set it aside once it’s all silky and delicious.

3. Cook the seafood

In the same skillet, melt the remaining 1/2 tablespoon of butter, then toss in the shrimp and lobster. You only need to cook them for a few minutes on each side until they turn opaque. Be careful not to overcook – seafood gets tough fast! Once done, remove them from the heat.

4. Make the filling

In a large mixing bowl, combine the cooked shrimp, lobster, crab, cream cheese, spinach, 1/2 cup mozzarella, Parmesan, Old Bay seasoning, salt, and pepper. Stir it all together until it’s evenly mixed and creamy.

5. Assemble the shells

Now comes the fun part! Spoon about 1-2 tablespoons of the seafood mixture into each shell. You’ll want to be generous, but not so much that the shells are overflowing. Once stuffed, place each shell into the baking dish over the creamy sauce. Sprinkle the remaining mozzarella over the top.

6. Bake to perfection

Cover the dish with foil and bake at 350°F for about 20 minutes. Then, remove the foil and let it bake for another 5-10 minutes, just until the cheese on top turns a beautiful golden brown. Let it cool for a few minutes before digging in – trust me, your mouth will thank you!

Make it your own: variations and adaptations

• Gluten-free: To make this dish gluten-free, simply swap out the pasta shells for a gluten-free version and use a gluten-free flour blend for the sauce.
• Vegan twist: While this is a very seafood-heavy dish, you could try a plant-based version by using vegan cream cheese, almond milk, and seafood alternatives like hearts of palm or marinated tofu for texture.
• Low-carb option: If you’re watching carbs, you can skip the pasta shells altogether and use zucchini or eggplant slices as a base for the filling.
• Seasonal variations: In the summer, adding some fresh, sweet corn to the filling gives it a lovely brightness. In the winter, you might prefer adding some sun-dried tomatoes for a deeper, more savory flavor.

Serving suggestions: presentation matters!

To make these seafood stuffed shells even more inviting, I love to serve them family-style right out of the baking dish. Add a sprinkle of fresh parsley or a bit more grated Parmesan on top for a pop of color. Pair it with a crisp green salad and some crusty garlic bread to soak up any extra sauce. Trust me, you won’t want to leave any behind!

beverage pairings

When it comes to non-alcoholic drinks, a crisp, refreshing option will work wonders to balance out the richness of the dish. A sparkling water with a squeeze of lemon or lime adds a nice touch of acidity. For something a bit sweeter, a cold glass of iced green tea with a hint of honey is light and complementary. If you’re serving this dish during colder months, a hot herbal tea like chamomile can provide a soothing contrast to the creamy seafood.

Storing and reheating leftovers

If you have leftovers (which, let’s be honest, you might not), these seafood stuffed shells store well in an airtight container in the fridge for up to three days. To reheat, cover the dish with foil and warm in a 350°F oven for about 15-20 minutes, or until heated through. You can also reheat individual servings in the microwave, but the oven keeps the texture of the shells a bit better. If the sauce thickens up too much, add a splash of milk or cream when reheating to bring it back to its creamy goodness.

Scaling the recipe: perfect for a crowd

Need to feed a larger group? You can easily double this recipe and bake it in two 9×13 pans. The only thing to note is that when you’re increasing the quantities, you might need to add a few more minutes to the baking time to ensure everything is heated through. I’ve also made this for a smaller group by halving the recipe and using an 8×8 pan, and it works just as well.

FAQs about seafood stuffed shells

1. Can I freeze the stuffed shells?
Yes! Assemble the shells and sauce, then freeze them unbaked. When you’re ready to eat, thaw them in the fridge overnight and bake as directed.

2. What can I substitute for lobster?
You can use more shrimp or even some scallops as a great substitute.

3. How do I avoid overcooking the seafood?
Cook the shrimp and lobster just until opaque and remove them from the heat right away. They’ll finish cooking when baked.

4. Can I use frozen seafood?
Absolutely! Just be sure to thaw and drain it well before using to avoid extra moisture.

5. Can I make the dish ahead of time?
Yes, you can assemble the shells and keep them in the fridge for up to a day before baking. Perfect for prepping ahead!

Print