Easy 4 Ingredient Buckeyes Peanut Butter Balls Recipe

If you’ve never had the joy of biting into a Buckeye, you’re in for a real treat. These bite-sized delights combine the creamy richness of peanut butter with the indulgence of dark chocolate, all with just four simple ingredients. And let me tell you, these are the kind of treats that disappear way too quickly at holiday parties or family gatherings. They’re deceptively simple, but the result is always a show-stopper.

I still remember the first time I made Buckeyes. I was trying to impress my in-laws during their annual Christmas cookie swap. I had exactly one afternoon to pull something together, and my fridge was looking pretty sparse. With only peanut butter, butter, powdered sugar, and a bag of melting chocolate, Buckeyes seemed like the perfect choice. Spoiler: they were a hit, and my mother-in-law even asked for the recipe!

Now, I make these little peanut butter balls every holiday season—and sometimes just because I’m craving that classic peanut butter-chocolate combo. Whether you’re looking for a quick and easy dessert or a crowd-pleasing gift idea, these Buckeyes have you covered.

this RECIPE

A little Buckeye backstory

These treats take their name from the Buckeye tree, which produces shiny, dark brown nuts with a light tan spot in the center—much like the partially dipped chocolate appearance of the candies. They originated in Ohio, where the Buckeye nut is the state symbol. While Buckeyes are traditionally a Christmas staple, they’ve made their way into dessert tables and snack trays year-round. Over time, this classic recipe has evolved, but the essentials—a creamy peanut butter core and a sweet chocolate coating—remain unchanged.

Let’s talk ingredients: Simple yet magical

• Salted butter: Softened butter is key to getting that smooth, creamy texture in the peanut butter mixture. Unsalted butter works too; just add a pinch of salt to balance the sweetness.
• Creamy peanut butter: The star of the show. Go for classic, no-stir peanut butter (the kind you’d smear on a sandwich). Natural peanut butter might separate, making the texture a bit trickier to work with. Crunchy peanut butter? Sure, if you like a bit of texture in your Buckeyes!
• Powdered sugar: This sweetens and binds the peanut butter mixture. Make sure it’s sifted to avoid lumps—though honestly, I’ve skipped the sifting step in a pinch, and they’ve still turned out great.
• Dark chocolate melting wafers: Melting wafers are my go-to because they’re easy to work with and set beautifully. If you don’t have them on hand, you can use chocolate chips with a teaspoon of coconut oil or shortening to make the dipping easier.

Kitchen gear: What you’ll need (and what you can skip)

You don’t need a ton of tools for this recipe, which is part of its charm. Here’s what I recommend:

• Mixing bowl and spoon/spatula: To combine the peanut butter mixture. If you’ve got a hand mixer, you can use it to save some arm power.
• Cookie scoop or tablespoon: This helps ensure evenly sized Buckeyes.
• Wax paper or parchment paper: For lining the baking sheet and keeping things from sticking.
• Toothpicks: For dipping! A fork works too, but toothpicks make it easier to get that perfect “buckeye” look.

Step-by-step: Rolling and dipping like a pro

1. Mix the magic: Start by combining the softened butter, creamy peanut butter, and powdered sugar in a large bowl. It should come together into a thick, slightly sticky dough. If it’s too sticky, add a bit more powdered sugar. (Pro tip: Don’t skimp on the mixing—you want everything smooth and well-combined.)
2. Shape it up: Scoop out about a tablespoon of the mixture and roll it between your palms to form a ball. Try to make them as smooth and round as possible. If the mixture feels too soft to roll, pop it in the fridge for 10 minutes to firm up. Place each ball onto a wax paper-lined baking sheet.
3. Chill out: Insert a toothpick into the center of each ball and chill the tray in the fridge or freezer for about 30 minutes. This step is crucial—cold peanut butter balls are much easier to dip in chocolate without falling apart.
4. Melt the chocolate: Follow the directions on your chocolate melting wafers. If you’re using chocolate chips, melt them in 20-second intervals in the microwave, stirring in between, and add a teaspoon of coconut oil for a glossy finish.
5. The fun part—dipping: Grab your chilled peanut butter balls and dip them into the melted chocolate, leaving a small circle of peanut butter exposed at the top (to mimic a Buckeye nut). Let the excess chocolate drip off, then place them back onto the wax paper.
6. Final chill: Once all the Buckeyes are dipped, pop the tray back into the fridge for 15-20 minutes until the chocolate is fully set. If you’re feeling fancy, you can smooth over the toothpick holes with your finger, but honestly, they’re adorable either way.

Variations you’ll love to try

• Vegan Buckeyes: Swap butter for vegan butter and use dairy-free chocolate. Many powdered sugars are vegan, but it’s worth double-checking the label.
• Keto-friendly: Use a powdered erythritol sweetener instead of powdered sugar and opt for sugar-free chocolate chips.
• Nutty upgrades: Mix crushed peanuts into the peanut butter mixture for added crunch or try almond or cashew butter for a new twist on flavor.
• Holiday vibes: Add festive sprinkles on top of the chocolate before it sets for a cheerful, seasonal touch.

How to serve and wow your guests

For presentation, I like to arrange my Buckeyes on a pretty platter lined with parchment paper, or sometimes I’ll stack them in a cute tin if I’m gifting them. A sprinkle of flaky sea salt on the chocolate before it sets also gives them an elevated, bakery-like touch. Pair them with a platter of sugar cookies or fudge for a perfect holiday dessert spread.

Drinks that pair perfectly

I love serving Buckeyes with a warm drink like hot cocoa, chai tea, or a rich espresso. They’re also amazing with a glass of cold milk—classic, right? If you’re celebrating with grown-ups, a small glass of port wine or a creamy Baileys on ice makes a decadent pairing.

Storage and reheating tips

Buckeyes store beautifully! Keep them in an airtight container in the fridge for up to two weeks. If you’re planning ahead, they freeze well too—just layer them between sheets of wax paper in a freezer-safe container. Let them thaw in the fridge for a few hours before serving.

Scaling up or down

This recipe makes about 20 Buckeyes, but it’s super easy to scale. If you’re making a bigger batch, just make sure your peanut butter mixture stays chilled—it’s easier to roll and dip when cold. For smaller batches, halve the recipe and adjust your chocolate melting accordingly.

What if things go wrong?

• Mixture too sticky? Chill it for 10-15 minutes before rolling, or add a little more powdered sugar.
• Chocolate clumping? Stir in a teaspoon of coconut oil or shortening to smooth it out.
• Peanut butter balls falling apart while dipping? Make sure they’re cold enough—chilling is key to keeping their shape.

Time to get dipping!

So there you have it—a simple, fail-proof recipe for Buckeyes that will make you feel like a pro chocolatier. They’re a little nostalgic, a little indulgent, and a whole lot of delicious. The best part? You can tweak them to fit any occasion or dietary preference, making them a must-have in your dessert repertoire.

FAQ

Q: Can I use crunchy peanut butter?
A: Absolutely! It’ll add a nice crunch to the texture.

Q: Do I need to refrigerate Buckeyes?
A: Yes, it’s best to keep them chilled so the chocolate stays firm.

Q: What kind of chocolate works best?
A: Dark chocolate melting wafers are ideal, but semi-sweet or milk chocolate chips with a bit of coconut oil work too.

Q: Can I freeze them?
A: Yes! Just store them in an airtight container and thaw in the fridge when ready to serve.

Q: How long do Buckeyes last?
A: Up to two weeks in the fridge and about two months in the freezer.

Print