Hocus Pocus Milkshake Recipe

This magical-inspired milkshake isn’t just fun and refreshing but also deliciously creamy with a zesty lime twist. Whether you’re planning to gather friends or simply want to enjoy a special drink at home, this milkshake will leave a great impression on anyone who tries it. Plus, it’s super easy to make, so even if you’re short on time, you can whip it up quickly and enjoy a delightful, tasty experience!

this RECIPE

🍵 My first time making this magic potion

I remember the first time I made this milkshake; I was hosting a movie night with a few friends. We were watching “Hocus Pocus” (of course!) when I realized I wanted to add something fun to the mix—something that felt just as whimsical as the Sanderson sisters themselves. Lime sherbet happened to be in my freezer, and after a quick experiment with some food coloring and candy eyes, this milkshake was born! The bright neon green color was so perfectly witchy that it instantly became the star of the night. Ever since then, this has been my go-to treat, and trust me, it’s always a hit!

The origin story behind this wickedly fun drink

Inspired by the neon green of witch’s brews and the goofy charm of the “Hocus Pocus” movie, this recipe blends nostalgia and fun into every sip. Lime sherbet gives it that tangy, citrusy flavor while the candy eyes and sprinkles bring the “creepy” factor. Fun fact: lime sherbet has been used in retro punch recipes for decades, often paired with soda for fizzy fun at parties. Now, we’re giving it a modern, magical spin!

Let’s talk ingredients: sherbet, milk, and spooky toppings!

• Lime Sherbet: This is the star of the show, giving the milkshake its unique flavor and neon green color. If you’re out of lime sherbet, lemon sherbet or even vanilla ice cream with a few drops of lime juice could work in a pinch.
• Whole Milk: The milk helps smooth out the sherbet, making the shake creamy. You could swap in almond milk or oat milk if you need a dairy-free option, but I find whole milk gives the richest texture.
• Neon Green Food Gel: Just a drop will intensify that witchy green color! If you don’t have it, you can skip this step, but trust me, the color really adds to the magic.
• Whipped Cream: The whipped cream gives that extra touch of indulgence and makes it perfect for piling on spooky toppings. I prefer canned whipped cream for easy swirling, but homemade works too.

Kitchen gear: What you need (and what you can totally skip)

For this recipe, the good news is you won’t need much in terms of fancy equipment! Here’s what I use:

• Blender: A blender is key to getting the sherbet and milk perfectly smooth. If you don’t have one, you could mix everything in a bowl with a whisk, but it’ll take a bit more elbow grease.
• Milkshake glass or tall cup: A classic tall milkshake glass really lets this drink shine. But any cup will do if you’re in a pinch.
• Ice cream scoop: It makes getting even scoops of sherbet easier, but a large spoon will work if that’s what you have.

Honestly, this recipe is so simple, you probably already have everything you need in your kitchen!

Step-by-step: My foolproof method (and a few hard-learned lessons)

1. Blend the basics: Start by adding 4 scoops of lime sherbet into your blender. I find four scoops give the perfect balance of flavor and thickness. Then, pour in 1 cup of whole milk. Add a drop of neon green food gel to amp up the color. Blend until the mixture is smooth and creamy. (A little tip: If your shake seems too thick, add a splash more milk; too runny, add another small scoop of sherbet!)
2. Pour and prep: Once the milkshake is blended, pour it into a tall glass, leaving a bit of room at the top for the toppings. I learned this the hard way after a few messy overflow situations—always leave space for the fun stuff on top!
3. Whipped cream time: Now for the best part—topping! Grab your can of whipped cream and swirl it high. I love seeing how tall I can make the peak before it starts tipping. If you’re feeling extra fancy, you can use a piping bag to get a more decorative swirl, but a good ol’ can works perfectly.
4. Add the spookiness: Finish it off by sprinkling green, purple, and black sprinkles over the whipped cream. Don’t forget the candy eyes! Place a few around the whipped cream so they look like they’re watching you.

Variations: Making this milkshake your own

One of the things I love about this Hocus Pocus milkshake is how customizable it is. Here are a few variations I’ve tried:

• Dairy-free: If you or your guests are avoiding dairy, swap out the whole milk for almond milk, coconut milk, or oat milk, and use a dairy-free whipped topping. For the sherbet, you can use a dairy-free lime sorbet instead. The texture will be a bit icier but still delicious!
• Vegan twist: To make the milkshake entirely plant-based, combine the dairy-free sherbet and milk options, then top with coconut whipped cream.
• Different flavors: Not a fan of lime? You can easily switch up the flavor by using orange sherbet for a Jack-o’-lantern-inspired shake or even raspberry sherbet for a ghoulish red drink!

Serving up the magic: Presentation ideas

Serve this milkshake in tall, clear glasses to really show off that bright green color. For an extra spooky touch, you can rim the glass with black sugar or even dip the rim in melted chocolate and let it drip down the sides like a bubbling cauldron. You can also add extra candy eyes around the base of the whipped cream or use gummy worms hanging off the edge for an added creepy factor. It’s all about having fun with it!

Drink pairings: Sipping alongside your milkshake

Now, since this is a rich and creamy milkshake, I’d recommend pairing it with something light and refreshing if you want to offer more drinks. Here are a few ideas:

• Lemonade: A tangy homemade lemonade balances out the sweetness of the milkshake beautifully.
• Iced tea: Go for a lightly sweetened iced tea with a lemon twist. It adds a refreshing, crisp contrast.
• Sparkling water: For something even lighter, a glass of sparkling water with a slice of lime or lemon keeps things bubbly and fun without overpowering the shake.

Storing your leftover potion

If by some miracle you don’t finish your milkshake (although I rarely see that happening), you can store it in the freezer. Just pop it into a freezer-safe container, and when you’re ready for round two, let it thaw slightly on the counter and give it a quick blend to get the texture back. Be aware that it might lose some of its creaminess after freezing, so it’s best enjoyed fresh. And when it comes to the whipped cream and toppings? Always add those just before serving to keep them looking fresh and fun!

Adjusting for different party sizes

This recipe makes one generous milkshake, but it’s super easy to scale up if you’re serving a crowd. Just multiply the ingredients by however many servings you need. For example, if you’re making shakes for four people, use 16 scoops of sherbet, 4 cups of milk, and so on. The only thing to watch out for is blending in batches if your blender can’t handle all that at once. Also, be prepared to have a topping assembly line—it’s a fun way to get everyone involved in decorating their own spooky shake!

Troubleshooting: Avoid these spell-breaking mishaps

• Too thick? Add a splash more milk and blend again until it reaches your desired consistency.
• Too runny? Toss in an extra scoop of sherbet to thicken things up.
• Blending issues? If your blender’s struggling to mix everything smoothly, try softening the sherbet slightly before blending.

Time to brew your own Hocus Pocus milkshake!

There’s something so fun about a festive, colorful drink like this one. Whether you’re throwing a party or just indulging in a movie night at home, this milkshake is a must-try. Play around with the toppings, make it your own, and don’t be afraid to get creative. Your taste buds (and your guests) will thank you!

Frequently asked questions

1. Can I use ice cream instead of sherbet?
Sure! If you prefer ice cream, go for it. Vanilla with a splash of lime juice works great.

2. What if I don’t have neon green food gel?
No worries, you can skip it. The lime sherbet already gives the shake a great green hue.

3. How long will the milkshake stay fresh?
It’s best enjoyed fresh, but you can store it in the freezer for up to 1 day.

4. Can I make this ahead of time?
I recommend making it right before serving for the best texture and presentation.

5. What’s the best way to make this shake less sweet?
Try using unsweetened almond milk or cutting back on the whipped cream and toppings.

Print