Lobster Roll Recipe

There’s something undeniably comforting about a warm lobster roll. The sweet, tender lobster meat, lightly dressed with fresh herbs and butter, nestled in a toasted bun—what’s not to love? It’s the perfect blend of indulgence and simplicity, making you feel like you’re indulging in something fancy, even though it’s so easy to make. This lobster roll recipe has become my go-to for quick summer lunches or casual dinners, especially when I want to impress with minimal effort. Whether you’re enjoying it by the beach or at home, this dish brings all the vibes of a classic New England lobster shack right to your kitchen.

Now, I’ll be honest—my first experience with lobster rolls was not at some picturesque seafood shack on the coast, but rather, in my tiny kitchen, where I was feeling adventurous (and maybe a little overconfident). I had just watched some travel show about Maine and thought, “I could totally pull this off.” Spoiler alert: the first attempt was not great. I overcooked the lobster, and the rolls were… let’s just say, less than golden. But once I figured out the balance between buttery lobster and perfectly toasted buns, I was hooked. This recipe has come a long way since that first try, and now I’m thrilled to share my foolproof version with you.

this RECIPE

🍋 The magic of simplicity: why this lobster roll is a must-try

Lobster rolls are one of those dishes that let the ingredients do the talking. You don’t need a ton of fancy techniques or obscure ingredients—just fresh lobster, butter, herbs, and a little citrus. The combination of melted butter and lemon juice enhances the natural sweetness of the lobster, while the fresh chives and dill add just the right amount of herbal brightness. What really sets this lobster roll recipe apart is its simplicity. It’s all about celebrating the delicate flavor of lobster without overpowering it.

This version is also great because it’s super adaptable. If you have access to fresh lobster, fantastic! If not, frozen lobster tails will do the trick. And let’s be honest, lobster is one of those ingredients that’s always going to feel a little luxurious no matter how you prepare it.

A quick dive into the lobster roll’s history

The lobster roll has its roots in New England, particularly in Maine, where lobster is abundant. In fact, the lobster roll as we know it likely came about in the 1920s at a restaurant called Perry’s in Milford, Connecticut. Back then, lobster was more of a “working-class” food, and the roll was designed as a quick, portable way to enjoy it. Over time, lobster rolls became a summer staple, with variations popping up across the country. The classic Maine-style lobster roll keeps things simple, usually featuring cold lobster meat with just a touch of mayo or butter, while some other versions (like the Connecticut style) serve the lobster warm, drenched in butter. This recipe is my personal take, leaning toward the Connecticut style with warm, buttery lobster.

Let’s talk ingredients: choosing the best for your lobster roll

The beauty of this lobster roll recipe lies in its minimal ingredient list. But since the dish is so simple, the quality of the ingredients really matters.

• Lobster: Of course, the star of the show. You’ll need about 3 cups of chopped, cooked lobster for this recipe, which comes from 7-8 lobster tails (about 4 oz each). If you’re using frozen tails, make sure to thaw them properly and avoid overcooking the meat. If you can find fresh lobster, even better—it’ll give the roll that extra “wow” factor. Don’t have lobster on hand? You could sub in shrimp or even crab for a different take, though it won’t quite have that lobster richness.
• Butter: Melted butter is the key to keeping the lobster moist and flavorful. You’ll need it both for the lobster mixture and for brushing on the buns. If you’re feeling extra fancy, you could use clarified butter, but regular melted butter works perfectly.
• Fresh Herbs (Chives & Dill): Chives bring a mild oniony flavor, while dill adds a subtle freshness that complements the lobster. If you’re out of chives, green onions are a decent substitute, and parsley can stand in for dill in a pinch.
• Lemon Juice: A little squeeze of lemon goes a long way in cutting through the richness of the butter and bringing some brightness to the dish. You don’t need much, just the juice from half a lemon.
• Hot Dog Buns: The bun is a crucial part of any lobster roll. You want something soft but sturdy enough to hold up to the lobster filling. Classic hot dog-style buns work well here, but if you can find split-top buns, they’re ideal because they toast more evenly.

Kitchen gear: what you need (and what you can skip)

You don’t need much in the way of equipment for this lobster roll recipe, which is one of the reasons I love it. Here’s what I usually use:

• A good knife: Since you’ll be chopping the lobster meat into bite-sized pieces, a sharp knife is essential. It’ll help you get even chunks without tearing the delicate meat.
• A mixing bowl: You’ll need a medium-sized bowl to toss the lobster with the butter, herbs, and lemon juice.
• Baking sheet: This is for warming the buns. You can toast them right in the oven on a baking sheet, or if you prefer, you can use a skillet or griddle.
• Pastry brush: For brushing the buns with butter. If you don’t have a pastry brush, just use the back of a spoon.

Step-by-step: making the perfect lobster roll

Alright, let’s get cooking! Follow these easy steps, and you’ll have warm, buttery lobster rolls ready in no time.

1. Cook your lobster: If you haven’t already cooked your lobster, start there. You can steam, boil, or even grill your lobster tails. Just make sure not to overcook them—lobster should be tender, not chewy. Once cooked, let it cool slightly before chopping into bite-sized pieces.
2. Mix it up: In a bowl, combine the chopped lobster with 3 tablespoons of melted butter, chopped chives, dill, and a squeeze of fresh lemon juice. Toss everything gently so the lobster is well-coated in the buttery, herby goodness. Season with salt and pepper to taste.
3. Toast the buns: Preheat your oven to 350°F. Brush the inside of your hot dog buns with a little melted butter, and place them on a baking sheet. Pop them in the oven for 4-5 minutes until they’re warm and just slightly toasted. This step adds a nice crunch to the soft buns.
4. Assemble the rolls: Once the buns are warm, spoon the lobster mixture generously into each one. Don’t be shy here—you want a good amount of lobster in every bite! Sprinkle with a little extra chive for garnish.
5. Serve and enjoy: Serve the lobster rolls immediately while they’re warm. Trust me, the combination of warm buttered lobster and freshly toasted buns is out of this world.

Fun variations to try

I’ve played around with a few different versions of this recipe, and here are some fun twists:

• Mayo-based lobster roll: If you prefer the Maine-style lobster roll, swap the butter for a light mayo dressing. Mix the lobster with a tablespoon or two of mayo, a dash of lemon juice, and your herbs.
• Spicy lobster roll: Add a little kick by stirring some Sriracha or cayenne into the melted butter before tossing it with the lobster. It gives a subtle heat that pairs beautifully with the sweetness of the lobster.
• Gluten-free option: No problem if you need to skip the traditional buns. Look for gluten-free rolls or serve the lobster salad over a bed of greens for a lighter, gluten-free version.
• Seasonal twist: In the summer, add a few diced cherry tomatoes or corn kernels to the mix for a bright, seasonal twist. It adds a nice bit of texture and color.

Serving and presentation ideas

When it comes to serving lobster rolls, I like to keep things simple and let the dish shine. Arrange the rolls on a platter, maybe with some extra lemon wedges on the side for squeezing. A sprinkle of extra chives over the top adds a nice pop of green. If you want to serve them with sides, potato chips, coleslaw, or a simple green salad all work beautifully. The rolls themselves are filling, so light sides work best.

Suggested drinks

you want something crisp and refreshing to balance the richness of the lobster. I often serve these with an ice-cold sparkling lemonade or a citrusy mocktail. Cucumber water or iced green tea with a squeeze of lemon are also great options that won’t overwhelm the delicate flavors of the lobster.

How to store and reheat leftovers

Lobster rolls are best enjoyed fresh, but if you have leftovers, store the lobster mixture separately from the buns in an airtight container in the fridge. The lobster will keep for about 2 days. To reheat, gently warm the lobster in a pan with a little extra butter (you don’t want to microwave it, or it’ll turn rubbery). Toast fresh buns before serving again.

Scaling the recipe for a crowd

This recipe makes 4 lobster rolls, but you can easily double or triple it if you’re feeding a crowd. Just make sure you have enough lobster—about 6-8 lobster tails for a double batch. If you scale up, be careful not to overcrowd your bowl when mixing the lobster, butter, and herbs. You want everything to be evenly coated.

Common issues (and how to avoid them!)

• Overcooking the lobster: This is the most common mistake, and it’s easy to do since lobster cooks quickly. Keep an eye on it, and remove it from the heat as soon as it’s opaque and slightly firm to the touch.
• Soggy buns: Toasting the buns is key! If you skip this step, the butter can make the buns soggy. A quick toast in the oven ensures they stay crispy and hold up to the lobster.

Time to dig in!

Lobster rolls are one of those dishes that feel like a little bit of luxury without a lot of fuss. Whether you’re making these for a casual lunch or a special dinner, I hope you enjoy this recipe as much as I do. Feel free to tweak it to your taste and make it your own—that’s half the fun of cooking, after all!

FAQs

1. Can I use frozen lobster tails?
Yes! Just make sure to thaw them completely before cooking, and be careful not to overcook the lobster meat.

2. What’s the difference between Maine and Connecticut-style lobster rolls?
Maine-style is usually served cold with a mayo dressing, while Connecticut-style is warm with butter. This recipe leans more toward the Connecticut style.

3. How do I avoid overcooking the lobster?
Keep an eye on it while cooking and remove it from heat as soon as it turns opaque and firm. It cooks fast!

4. What can I substitute for chives and dill?
Green onions can replace chives, and parsley or tarragon can substitute for dill.

5. Can I make this recipe ahead of time?
You can prep the lobster mixture a few hours in advance, but wait to toast the buns and assemble the rolls until just before serving.

Print