No Bake Eggnog Pie Recipe

If you’re like me, when the holiday season rolls around, eggnog starts making its way into everything I bake, cook, and sip. There’s just something about its rich, creamy texture and that distinct nutmeg aroma that feels like a cozy, festive hug. And while I’m all for classic recipes, sometimes I want something that’s quick, simple, and—most importantly—doesn’t require the oven. Enter the No-Bake Eggnog Pie. It’s one of those desserts that looks and tastes like you spent hours on it, but it’s ridiculously easy to make. Trust me, this is the perfect holiday dessert to whip up when you’re in a pinch or just want to avoid turning on the oven.

I have a funny story about the first time I made this pie. It was the night before a family holiday party, and I realized I hadn’t made anything for dessert. Total panic mode. I scoured my pantry, and as luck would have it, I had everything for this pie. So, I threw it together, let it chill overnight, and it was a hit. My secret was safe—until now!

this RECIPE

The comforting story behind eggnog pies

Eggnog itself dates back to medieval times, but the idea of turning it into a no-bake pie? That’s a more recent, modern-day holiday miracle. In the past, eggnog pies were baked, made from scratch, and often featured a custard base. But with the advent of instant pudding mixes and whipped topping, the no-bake version became a go-to for busy holiday bakers.

Key ingredients: flavor, texture, and a hint of holiday magic

Virgin eggnog

Ah, the star of the show. Eggnog brings that rich, creamy base and all those cozy spices like nutmeg and cinnamon that make it feel like the holidays. If you can’t find virgin eggnog or prefer a non-dairy alternative, try using almond or oat milk eggnog—it works surprisingly well. Just make sure whatever eggnog you use, it’s nice and cold for the best texture.

Vanilla instant pudding mix

This is the secret weapon that transforms this pie from liquid to luscious in minutes. I love using vanilla pudding because it complements the eggnog’s flavors without overpowering them. But, if you’re feeling adventurous, try using a white chocolate pudding mix for an even richer taste.

Whipped cream

Whipped cream is what gives this pie its fluffy, cloud-like texture. You can go the store-bought route (super convenient) or make your own if you’re feeling fancy. I’ve found that making it from scratch adds a bit more freshness to the pie, but let’s be real—store-bought works just as well in a pinch.

Ground nutmeg

No eggnog pie would be complete without a dash of nutmeg. It’s the spice that ties everything together and gives the pie that authentic holiday flavor. If you don’t have nutmeg, you could substitute it with cinnamon, though the flavor will be slightly different. Freshly grated nutmeg is even better if you have it on hand!

The kitchen tools you’ll need (and can probably skip)

This pie is as low-maintenance as it gets, and you won’t need any fancy tools to make it happen. A simple hand mixer is the MVP here—it’ll help blend the pudding mix and eggnog until it’s nice and smooth. If you don’t have one, a sturdy whisk and some elbow grease will do the trick, but it’ll take a bit more effort. I also recommend a silicone spatula for folding in the whipped cream and spreading the filling evenly into the crust. Of course, you’ll need a pie dish if you’re making your own graham cracker crust, but if you’re using a store-bought crust (which, let’s be honest, makes life easier), it already comes in one!

Step-by-step guide to making the perfect no-bake eggnog pie

1. Mix the eggnog and pudding.
   Start by grabbing a medium bowl and pour in the eggnog and pudding mix. I like to use a hand mixer on medium speed to get the mixture really smooth. You’ll know it’s ready when it thickens slightly and has a silky texture. This usually takes about 2-3 minutes. Be careful not to overmix, though—too much air can make the pie filling too fluffy (learned that the hard way).
2. Fold in the whipped cream and nutmeg.
   Once your eggnog-pudding base is ready, it’s time to fold in the whipped cream. This is where the pie gets its light, airy texture. Be gentle when folding—you don’t want to deflate the whipped cream. Add half of the ground nutmeg at this stage for that signature spiced flavor.
3. Transfer to the crust.
   Now, pour your mixture into the graham cracker crust. Use your spatula to spread the filling evenly, making sure it reaches all the edges. It might look a little messy at first, but a few swipes with the spatula should smooth things out beautifully.
4. Sprinkle and chill.
   For the finishing touch, sprinkle the remaining nutmeg over the top of the pie. Cover the pie and pop it into the fridge. The key to a good no-bake pie is giving it time to firm up. I like to let it chill for at least 5 hours, but overnight is even better. Trust me, the wait is worth it!

Variations to try (because who doesn’t love options?)

The best part about this no-bake eggnog pie is how versatile it is. Over the years, I’ve experimented with different variations to suit different occasions and dietary needs.

• Gluten-free version: Simply swap out the graham cracker crust for a gluten-free version. Most grocery stores carry one, or you can make your own with gluten-free graham crackers and butter.
• Vegan twist: Use a plant-based eggnog (almond or coconut are my favorites), a dairy-free pudding mix, and coconut whipped cream. It’s just as creamy and delicious, and your vegan friends will thank you.
• Spiced-up version: Add a teaspoon of cinnamon and a pinch of ground cloves to the filling for an extra warm, spicy flavor.
• Chocolate drizzle: After the pie has set, drizzle melted dark chocolate over the top for an indulgent touch. It adds a nice contrast to the sweet, creamy filling.

How to serve your no-bake eggnog pie like a pro

When you’re ready to serve, slice the pie into generous wedges. I love topping each slice with an extra dollop of whipped cream and a dash of nutmeg or cinnamon for that extra festive flair. If you’re feeling fancy, garnish with a cinnamon stick or a few holiday-themed sprinkles. This pie is best served chilled, so make sure it stays in the fridge until the very last minute.

beverage pairings

Since this is a family-friendly dessert, I like to serve it with cozy, non-alcoholic drinks. A hot cup of spiced apple cider pairs wonderfully with the creamy, chilled pie. You could also brew some chai tea—the warm spices in the tea complement the nutmeg in the pie beautifully. For a cooler option, a tall glass of iced vanilla chai or even a simple hot chocolate would do the trick.

Storing and reheating tips

Got leftovers? Lucky you! This pie stores wonderfully in the fridge. Just cover it with plastic wrap or transfer slices to an airtight container. It should last about 3-4 days—if it doesn’t get devoured sooner. One thing to note: this pie isn’t great for freezing because the texture can change once thawed, becoming too watery. But honestly, with how easy it is to make, you can always whip up another one if needed!

Scaling the recipe for more (or fewer) servings

If you’re feeding a crowd, you can easily double the recipe and make it in a 9×13-inch pan for a pie that’s more like a dessert bar. The only thing to keep in mind when scaling up is the chilling time—it might take a bit longer to set if the pie is thicker. On the flip side, if you’re making this for a smaller group, you can halve the recipe and make it in a 6-inch pie dish.

Troubleshooting common issues

If your pie isn’t setting properly, it could be that the pudding mix wasn’t fully combined with the eggnog. Be sure to mix it well until thickened. If it’s too runny, let it chill for a little longer—overnight is always a safe bet!

FAQ

1. Can I make this pie ahead of time?
Yes, you can make it a day or two ahead! Just store it in the fridge until you’re ready to serve.

2. Can I use homemade whipped cream?
Absolutely! Homemade whipped cream will make the pie even more luscious, but store-bought works just as well.

3. How long does the pie need to chill?
At least 5 hours, but overnight is ideal for the best texture.

4. Can I make this pie in individual servings?
Definitely! You can portion the filling into small tart shells or even ramekins for cute, individual servings. Just be mindful that smaller servings may set a bit faster in the fridge.

5. What if I don’t have graham crackers?
You can use any cookie crust—gingersnaps or vanilla wafers would also be delicious.

Print