Patty Melt With Secret Sauce Recipe

A good patty melt is like the ultimate comfort food – melty cheese, juicy beef, and perfectly toasted bread. But this patty melt? Oh, it’s on a whole other level thanks to the secret sauce. This sauce adds a tangy, creamy kick that pulls everything together, making each bite more addictive than the last. And then there’s the caramelized onions – slow-cooked until they’re sweet and golden. Trust me, this is one of those recipes where every single ingredient earns its place.

I’ve been making this patty melt for years, and it never disappoints. It started as a bit of an experiment to jazz up a regular grilled cheese and burger night, and now it’s a family favorite. Every time I make it, I remember how shocked I was the first time I tried this combo of Swiss and cheddar with caramelized onions. I mean, who would’ve thought it would make such a difference? Now I can’t imagine a patty melt without it.

Let’s dig into how to make this patty melt perfection happen in your kitchen!

this RECIPE

A little history: Where did the patty melt come from?

The patty melt has roots in American diner culture, originating in the 1940s or 50s when diners were known for their creative spins on comfort food classics. The idea was simple: take the best parts of a cheeseburger and a grilled cheese, then add a layer of caramelized onions for good measure. Traditionally served on rye bread and often made with Swiss cheese, the patty melt has since evolved with endless variations. Today, you’ll find different cheeses, sauces, and even bread choices, but at its core, a patty melt is all about that delicious blend of meat, cheese, and toasted bread.

Key ingredients for the perfect patty melt

Each ingredient in this recipe has a role to play, so let’s break down what makes them special:

• Ground beef: I recommend 85/15 ground beef for just the right amount of fat. The fat content keeps the patty juicy without turning greasy. If you prefer leaner beef, you can use it, but you might need to add a splash of oil to the skillet to prevent sticking.
• Rye bread: This bread has a distinctive flavor that pairs beautifully with the richness of the beef and cheese. If you’re not a fan of rye, sourdough or whole wheat are decent alternatives, but rye really makes it feel like a true patty melt.
• Swiss and cheddar cheese: This combo creates the best melt factor. Swiss cheese adds that mild, nutty flavor, while cheddar brings sharpness. If you’re missing one, you could sub in provolone or even American cheese.
• Onions: Caramelized onions add a sweet, savory layer to the melt. Yellow onions work best here for their sweetness, but white or red onions can also be used in a pinch.
• Secret sauce: This sauce is a mix of mayo, ketchup, mustard, pickle juice, paprika, and garlic powder. It’s creamy, tangy, and just a little smoky. If you like a kick, add a dash of hot sauce to the mix!

Essential kitchen tools you’ll need

To make this patty melt as fuss-free as possible, here are the tools I recommend:

• A good skillet: A cast-iron skillet is ideal for getting that golden crust on the bread and a nice sear on the patties. If you don’t have one, any heavy-bottomed pan will do.
• Spatula: You’ll need a sturdy spatula for flipping the sandwiches without everything sliding out. If you have a long spatula, it’s even better for managing those larger slices of bread.
• Mixing bowls: A couple of small bowls will come in handy for mixing the sauce and seasoning the beef.
• Sharp knife: A sharp knife makes slicing the onions much easier, and thin, even slices are key for caramelizing them properly.
• Butter knife: For spreading the butter evenly on the bread without tearing it.

Step-by-step: Crafting the perfect patty melt (with all my best tips)

1. Make the secret sauce

In a small bowl, combine ¼ cup of mayonnaise, 2 tablespoons ketchup, 1 tablespoon mustard, 1 teaspoon pickle juice, ¼ teaspoon paprika, and ¼ teaspoon garlic powder. Stir until smooth and set aside. This will be our magical sauce that ties the whole sandwich together.

2. Caramelize the onions

Heat 2 tablespoons of olive oil in a skillet over medium-low heat. Add two large, thinly sliced onions, and cook them slowly, stirring occasionally, for about 30 minutes. If the onions start to stick or dry out, add a splash of water to the pan. You’re aiming for soft, deeply golden onions. Don’t rush this step – the caramelization is what gives the onions their sweet, rich flavor.

Pro tip: Patience is key here! Caramelizing onions is a slow process, but it’s worth every minute. Keep the heat low, and don’t be afraid to add a bit of water if they start to brown too quickly.

3. Prepare the beef patties

In a mixing bowl, combine 12 ounces of ground beef with ½ teaspoon salt, ½ teaspoon pepper, and 1 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce. Mix well, then form into four thin, oblong patties – roughly the size and shape of your bread slices. The patties will shrink a bit as they cook, so aim for slightly larger than the bread.

4. Cook the patties

In the same skillet over medium heat, cook each patty for about 2-3 minutes per side, or until browned and cooked through. Set them aside on a plate. Don’t clean out the skillet – the little bits left behind add flavor when you grill the sandwiches.

5. Assemble the sandwiches

Butter one side of each slice of rye bread. Place a slice of bread in the skillet, buttered side down, and start layering: Swiss cheese, beef patty, caramelized onions, a generous spread of secret sauce, cheddar cheese, and then the other slice of bread (buttered side up).

6. Grill to golden perfection

With the sandwiches assembled, cook each one over medium heat for 1-2 minutes per side. Flip carefully to keep everything intact, and watch for that perfect golden-brown crust. The cheese should be melty and the bread nicely toasted.

Pro tip: If the bread is browning too fast before the cheese melts, lower the heat slightly and cover the skillet for a minute. This will help the cheese melt without burning the bread.

Mix it up: Variations and adaptations

If you want to put your own spin on this patty melt, here are some fun variations:

• Make it veggie: Swap the beef for a plant-based burger or a large portobello mushroom cap. Caramelize the mushroom just like the beef for extra flavor.
• Spicy patty melt: Add a few dashes of hot sauce to the secret sauce, or include a layer of pickled jalapeños for a spicy kick.
• Lower-carb option: For a low-carb twist, serve the patties with cheese and onions in lettuce wraps instead of bread. You’ll still get all those amazing flavors without the carbs.
• Try a different cheese combo: Swap the Swiss and cheddar for pepper jack and gouda for a new flavor profile.
• Seasonal variation: In the fall, try adding a few thin slices of apple between the cheese layers for a sweet, crisp contrast.

Serving suggestions: Make it a meal!

Serve these patty melts with a side of crispy French fries or a simple green salad to balance the richness. For a fun twist, try pairing them with sweet potato fries or a light cucumber salad for something refreshing.

To dress up the patty melt, sprinkle some chopped parsley or chives on top just before serving. It’s a small touch that adds a nice pop of color.

Beverage pairings

For a drink pairing, I love a cold iced tea with a slice of lemon for a refreshing contrast. If you’re a fan of milkshakes, a vanilla or chocolate shake makes this meal feel like a classic diner experience at home.

Storage and reheating tips

Patty melts are best fresh, but if you have leftovers, let them cool completely, then wrap in foil and refrigerate. To reheat, pop them in a skillet over medium heat, covered, until warmed through. The bread will crisp up nicely, and the cheese will re-melt. Avoid the microwave – it tends to make the bread soggy.

Food safety tip: Leftover patty melts should be eaten within 2 days for the best taste and safety.

Scaling the recipe

This recipe makes four sandwiches, but you can easily scale it up or down. If you’re cooking for a crowd, you can double or triple the ingredients. When making a single patty melt, just remember to adjust the seasonings in the beef and sauce to taste – a pinch of each works well for one sandwich.

Common questions

1. Can I make the secret sauce in advance?
Absolutely! You can make the sauce up to 3 days in advance and keep it in the fridge. It’s even better when the flavors have a little time to meld.

2. What’s the best bread for patty melts?
Rye bread is traditional, but sourdough or a sturdy whole wheat bread works well if you prefer a milder flavor.

3. How can I make this gluten-free?
Swap out the rye bread for your favorite gluten-free bread. Just make sure it’s thick enough to hold up in the skillet.

4. Can I caramelize the onions faster?
While you can cook them over medium heat, they won’t get as deeply caramelized. Stick to low and slow if you can for the best flavor.

5. What cheese can I use instead of Swiss?
Provolone, gouda, or mozzarella are all great alternatives if you’re not a fan of Swiss.

Enjoy your homemade patty melts with all the trimmings, and don’t forget to make extra sauce – you’ll want to dip your fries in it!

Print